Deceit in
American Government: Gulf of Tonkin
By BEN BRADLEE
 I would like to talk about government lying. Calculated lies. The willful
deception of the public for political end, especially under the disguise
of national security, and what an awful price we pay for such lies under
any name: misinformation, disinformation, deceit, deception, or just plain
dishonesty.
In America, the press is curiously shy, even embarrassed when faced with
the need to use some form of the verb 'to lie' even now when public
tolerance for the unexplained and for the unbelievable explanation is
wearing thin. We seem to drop quickly into a defensive crouch, when even,
as now, we are accused of abusing our power by not accepting explanations
which often defy acceptance. We are, too often, close enough to the
Establishment ourselves to be [un]comfortable in calling a lie, a lie. I
am not talking about little lies as in Vice-Admiral Poindexter asked to
give up his job as National Security Adviser to return to active duty in
the Navy. Little lies as in we did not trade the Soviet spy TK Sakharov
for the American journalist Nick Danilov. Little lies like Margaret
Heckler has been promoted from Secretary of Health and Human Services to
be Ambassador to Ireland. Little lies like that take forever to damage the
bonds of confidence that link the people and the press and public policy.
Let us talk about the big lies, lies that change history. Two of them have
to do with Vietnam, that war that so outraged Jimmy Cameron. Let me take
you back to December 1963 and Tan Son Hut airport in Saigon. At the end of
his first fact finding trip to Vietnam for the New American President
Lyndon Johnson, the Defense Secretary Robert McNamara was holding a press
conference. He told reporters that he was 'optimistic as to the progress
that had been made and could be made during the coming year' in the fight
against the Vietcong. This was duly reported to an anxious world on that
night's television and in next day's newspapers.
Landing at Andrews Air Force Base outside Washington next day, he told
another press conference: 'We have every reason to believe that (US
military plans for 1964) will be successful. ' And he disappeared into a
helicopter for the White House lawn, and a one-on-one session with the
President in the Oval Office. Also duly reported.
For 7 1/2 years, there was no report of that conversation. Not until July,
1971 and then only after the Nixon administration took the New York
Times and the Washington Post all the way to the Supreme Court
in a vain effort to keep them from publishing the so-called Pentagon
Papers, did we hear what McNamara really felt.
Buried in those Pentagon papers (which so few people ever read) lay the
revelation that McNamara had told President Johnson exactly the opposite
of what he had told the press and through us, the world. The Secretary of
Defense returned from Vietnam 'laden with gloom' according to documents in
the Pentagon papers. 'Vietcong progress had been great,' he reported to
the President, 'With my best guess being that the situation has in fact
been deteriorating to a far greater extent than we realize. The situation
is very disturbing.'
Think for a minute how history could have changed if those comments had
been made at Tan Son Hut airport, if those lies had gone unspoken at
Andrews Air Force Base. Reflect on one of the eternal verities of our
profession - insufficiently understood by us or by our readers - that the
truth, the whole truth, emerges over time, and that's the way its supposed
to be, as Lippmann pointed out more than 60 years ago. We don't get it
all, the first crack out of the box, for lots of reasons, including the
fact that people occasionally lie. It can take a long time to get it all,
and get it right.
Now
let me ask you to jump ahead some eight months to August 1964, still more
than 20 years ago, to There were
at least six of them, Russian-designed Swatow gunboats armed with 37-mm
and 28-mm guns, and P-4's. At 9.52 they opened fire on the destroyers with
automatic weapons, and this time from as close as 2,000 yards. The night
glowed early with the nightmarish glare of air dropped flares and boat's
searchlights. Two of the enemy boats went down. '
That's the kind of vivid detail that the news magazines have made famous.
I don't mean to single out Time. On the same date Life said
almost the same thing and that week's issue of Newsweek had
torpedoes whipping by, US ships blazing out salvo after salvo of shells.
It had a PT boat bursting into flames.
There was only one trouble. There was no battle. There was not a single
intruder, never mind six of them. Never mind Russian designed Swatow
gunboats armed with 37mm and 28mm guns. They never opened fire. They never
sank. They never fired torpedoes. They never were.
It has really taken 20 years for this truth to emerge. My authority is
Admiral Jim Stockdale, who has written a fascinating book. In Love
and War. Jim Stockdale was shot down over Vietnam a few days later
and was a prisoner of the Vietnamese for more than seven years.
 But on the night in question he was in a Sabre jet fighter flying cover
over the Maddox and the Turner Joy, and he scoured the seas for more than
two hours; and he is as sure as man can be that they were fighting phantom
blips on a radar screen.
In case the Vietnam years have blurred in your minds, or even disappeared
from your screens, may I remind you that this so-called Battle of Tonkin
Gulf was the sole basis of the Tonkin Gulf Resolution, which was the
entire justification for the United States' war against Vietnam. This
non-event happened on August 4, 1964. President Johnson went on television
that very night to ask the country to support a Congressional resolution.
The resolution went to Congress the next day. Two days later it was
approved unanimously by the House and 88-2 by the Senate.
The 'facts' behind this critically important resolution were quite simply
wrong. Misinformation? Disinformation? Deceit? Whatever! Lies.
(C) Guardian 1987 * Reprinted for Educational Use Only
|
Remembering Kent State 1970 When
thirteen students were shot by Ohio National Guard Troops during a war
demonstration on the Kent State University Campus on the first week of May
1970, four young lives were ended and a nation was stunned. More than 30
years later, the world at war is a different place. However, those
thirteen seconds in May,
1970 still remain scorched into an Ohio hillside. Through archival tape
and interviews, Remembering Kent State tracks the events that led up to
the shootings.
 Listen to Remembering
Kent State 1970 with Real Player |
The world gets crazier and crazier everyday, doesn't it? The world that many
of us thought was there, isn't. The bottom has dropped out of everything. The
illusions have been revealed, we have found out who has been pulling the strings
behind the scenes. Millions have lost their jobs, have mortgage
problems, and
foreclosure. What can be done? Amazingly, we have been mislead. We have been
taught that we can control government by voting. The founder of the Rothschild
dynasty, Mayer Amschel Bauer, told the secret of controlling the government
of a nation over 200 years ago. He said, "Permit
me to issue and control the money of a nation and I care not who makes its
laws." Get
the picture? Your freedom hinges first on the nation's banks and money system.
It's all about 'commerce'. Freedom is connected with Debt Elimination for
each individual. Not only does this end
personal debt, it places the people first in line
as creditors to the National Debt ahead of the banks. They don't wish for
you to know this. It has to do with recognizing WHO you really are in A
New Beginning: A Practical Course in Miracles, an informational study. Is
your credit rating bad for reasons that seem out of your control? There are
ways of credit repair,
so you can men those broken fences too. Do you want to keep your children protected
from outside forces, there are ways of protecting
your children. Do you want
to keep your sons and daughters free from 'the draft'? Check this out.
Disclaimer - The posting of stories, commentaries, reports, documents and links (embedded or otherwise) on this site does not in any way, shape or form, implied or otherwise, necessarily express or suggest endorsement or support of any of such posted material or parts therein.
The myriad of facts, conjecture, perspectives, viewpoints, opinions, analyses,
and information in the articles, stories and commentaries posted on this site
range from cutting edge hard news and comment to extreme and unusual perspectives.
We choose not to sweep uncomfortable material under the rug - where it can
grow and fester. We choose not to censor skewed logic and uncomfortable rhetoric.
These things reflect the world as it now is - for better and worse. We present
multiple facts, perspectives, viewpoints, opinions, analyses, and information. If
you have more information on a certain subject that verifies it, challenges
it or make a comment on it, please e.mail
us.
Journalism is (or used to be) the profession of gathering and presenting a broad panorama of news about the events of our times and presenting it to readers for their own consideration. We believe in the intelligence, judgment and wisdom of our readers to discern for themselves among the data which appears on this site that which is valid and worthy...or otherwise. See full legal disclaimer
 |
|
|
|
The
most effective CANDIDA
DEFENSE product
available. This proprietary formula is teeming with live bacteria
that start to work right away to help rid the body of tough
Candida organisms. visit
this site: ghtdirect.com/KARA
|
|
| |
|
| |
|
|
|
 |
11/18/09
In the News
-Sen.
Dodd on Warpath Against Fed
-Rise
in soldier suicides leaves Pentagon looking for answers
-Computer
games fan 'planned school massacre'
-Woman
awarded $3M in assault claim against KBR
-Al
Gore: Earth's Interior 'Extremely Hot, Several Million Degrees
-Internet
Under Seige
-video Water
Drop at 2000 Frames per Second
-A
glitch causes widespread US air travel delays
-Students
storm UCLA building to protest expected UC system fee increase [Updated]
-Couple
arrested for not paying 18% tip...(say what?)
11/18/09
In the News
-Maersk
Alabama repels 2nd pirate attack with guns
-DEADLY PNEUMONIC VIRUS STRANGLES
UKRAINE
-Mexican
Government Admits ET's are Real!
-Washington
Post: D.C. quietly folds up police checkpoint program
-More
than $98 billion in improper gov't payments
-Washington
Post: D.C. to pay $450,000 to war protesters over 2002 interrogation
-Judge:
Corps' negligence caused Katrina flooding
-CHINA:Children’s
hospital doctor on duty playing games, 5-month-old baby dies
-Government
Web site says stimulus created jobs in nonexistent districts
11/17/09
In the News
-BOMBSHELL:
Bin Laden worked for US until 9/11
-Man
says 30-foot 'monster' lurking in canals of Madeira Beac
-L.A.
water main breaks may be tied to reservoir, DWP says
11/16/09
In The News
-Farmers,
Ranchers Fighting Back Against FDA Tyranny Over Animal Farms
-AFGHANISTAN
/ THE BIG PICTURE
-Protesters:
IDF used .22-caliber ammo at West Bank fence
-Rabbit
Hole
-75,343
Bogus jobs 'created or saved' by the Stimulus
-Paul
Mirengoff: Why does he hate us? Barack Obama's America-effacing presidency
-Obama
- Don't Lecture China On Censorship
-Boy
on milk carton still missing after 30 years
-Girl's
body found in North Carolina, police say
-Oklahoma
doctor held in death of son, 9
-4.6
earthquake hits in San Bernardino County
-Millions
will have to repay part of tax credi
-Chinese
censors block Obama's call to free the Web
-AP
Poll: Americans fret over health overhaul costs
-Watchdog:
Gov't may have overpaid to bail out AIG
-Blue
lights installed in Tokyo train stations to stop suicides
-I
introduced Belle to vice girls: It showed her the 'human face' of
sex trade, says father
-Torture
Resisters Arrested at Fort Huachuca
11/15/09
In the News
-U.S.:
Army Sends Infant to Protective Services, Mom to Afghanistan
-HUGE
NEWS! FEDERAL JUDGE Carter sets Trial Date for Obama's Eligibility!!!
-Mystery
of Bangladesh's mass arsenic poisoning solved
-On
Abortion, Hypocrisy Reigns Among Blue Dog, Republicans & Christians
-A
Death in Tehran
-Pregnant
Women Reporting H1N1 Vax Miscarriages
-Fragile
Care Worsened Swine Flu in Ukraine
-Counties
in Kansas designated as disaster areas
-no
one at Columbia remember Mr. Obama
11/14/09
In the News
-AMERICA
IS ME
-Huge
Rise In Birth Defects In Falluja
-TV
evangelist jailed over child 'brides'
-Sleeping
boy attacked in Sydney home
-Obama
to attack guns as public-health?
11/13/09
In the News
-More
girls in India are refusing to become child brides
-NASA
finds water found on the moon
-Lawyer:
Accused Fort Hood gunman may be paralyzed
-Blasts
rip through Russian arms depot
-Facebook
crowdsourced investigation exposes vaccine denials of SIGA Technologies
-THE
REVOLT OF
THE FIFTH ESTATE / THE PEOPLE
-Suspect
sought in acid attack on South L.A. woman
-Woman ‘Incurably’ Crippled
by Vaccine Cured by Alternative Healer
11/12/09
In the News
-PREMEDITATED
MERGER
-Vaccine
Victims Blamed For National Emergency:
-How
the US army protects its trucks – by paying the Taliban
-Combivir:
The HIV Drug in Hasan's Shoe Box
-America's
Shameful Neglect
-Mujib
Rahman wanted to be the first Bangladeshi elected to New York's City
Council. His strategy: tell voters about his opponent's sexuality
-An
'Honor Flight' for WWII Vets
-Pressure
grows on Barack Obama as memos expose rifts over Afghan policy
-New
account of Fort Hood shooting may put another officer in spotlight
-Give
Us $7B or We Kill the Trees
-Bomb
hits Pakistan's spy agency in northwest
-Deputies
Hold Boy Who Fled Flu Shot
-Judge
Andrew Napolitano Natural rights Patriot Act - Part 3 of 3
-Join
reader action to educate the Associated Press about natural remedies,
alternative medicin
-Riverside
County prosecutors today announced a 155-count indictment in a large
public corruption investigation that includes charges against several
elected officials.
-Palin
in book: McCain aides kept me 'bottled up
-Feds
move to seize 4 mosques, tower linked to Iran
-Fed:
banks need customer consent on overdraft fees
For
more news
|
New information
on accessible
and affordable products that
kill mycoplasma and viruses!
polRN
Tired of trying to get that
old tile and grout clean?
Who You gonna call?
|
SALE
$2775.00 till 12/25/09
(free shipping up to $125
in continental U.S.)
The
Ten minute exerciser, all you have to do is find ten spare
minutes a few times a week to reach optimal results. 
Whole Body
Vibration is a fascinating new technology, and is being used
by celebrities and athletes
the world over. From hard bodies like Madonna and Gwen Stefani,
to champion Lance Armstrong, vibration exercise is the choice
among the fittest today. Many professional Sports teams now
use Whole Body Vibration in their training.
SALE
$2775.00
till 12/25/09
(free shipping up to $125
in continental U.S.)
For more information on the Noblerex
K1
Please Click
Here |
|
